Season 1 (2016)
Four Colored Girls Who Have Considered Suicide When the Rainbow is Enuf
Broadway Backwards
American Idiot
Five Women Wearing the Same Dress
Peter and the Star Catcher
Divas Cabaret I

Season 2 (2017)
Broadway Backwards
Bleacher Bums
Billy Elliot
Waiting for Godot
Divas Cabaret II

Season 3 (2018)
The Odd Couple – Female Version
Nunsense II – The Second Coming
Broadway Backwards
The Mountaintop
Stars of Tomorrow Student Production: 13: The Musical

Season 4 (2019)
Lost in Yonkers
Broadway Backwards
On the Exhale
Stars of Tomorrow Student Production: Emma! A Pop Musical
No Exit

Season 5 (2020 – 2022)
Bus Stop (Spring, 2020)
Doubt, A Parable (Fall, 2021)
Stars of Tomorrow Student Production: Puffs, or Seven Increasingly Eventful Years at a Certain School of Magic and Magic (Summer, 2022)

Season 6 (2023)
Leaving Iowa
Stars of Tomorrow Student Production: The Curious Case at Covingston Manor
My Little Titus Andronicus

Season 7 (2024)
Love Letters